Court Rejects Former Reinsurer Chief’s Bid for Third Term

Kenya Reinsurance Corporation (Kenya Re) is a prominent financial institution that provides “insurance for insurance companies” (reinsurance)
The Court of Appeal has upheld the dismissal of a legal challenge by Jadiah Mwarania, the former managing director of Kenya Reinsurance Corporation, ruling that he had neither an automatic right nor a legitimate expectation to a third five-year term after his contract expired.
In a judgment delivered July 10, the appellate court affirmed an earlier decision by the Employment and Labour Relations Court.
The dispute began after Kenya Re’s board recommended extending Mwarania’s tenure, citing the company’s strong financial performance, the value of institutional knowledge, and ongoing strategic projects.
However, the Cabinet secretary for the National Treasury, John Mbadi, declined to approve a full third term. Instead, the CS directed the board to launch a competitive recruitment process for a permanent successor while granting temporary one-year extensions.
Mwarania contested the decision in court, arguing that the Cabinet Secretary had unlawfully interfered with the board’s authority, violated his constitutional rights and undermined a legitimate expectation created by the board’s earlier recommendation for renewal.
The Court of Appeal, however, rejected those arguments. The judges acknowledged that the Kenya Re board had the power to appoint its chief executive but was also entitled to seek policy guidance from the National Treasury and the Head of Public Service.
While the board could theoretically have ignored that advice and proceeded with a third term, it chose instead to follow government direction and initiate succession planning, the judges observed.
Crucially, the court noted that Mwarania had signed both one-year extensions “voluntarily and out of his own free will” without protest, duress or claims of misrepresentation at the time.
“The appellant voluntarily and out of his own free will, accepted the last one year term. He was bound by that commitment and he could not now unilaterally extend this one year term to a five year term,” the court stated.
Claims of broader constitutional violations were also dismissed. The court characterised the case as a standard employment dispute over the renewal of a fixed-term contract rather than a matter warranting constitutional damages.



