Skip to content
TRENDING
News

Why Kenya’s Insurance Industry Has a Claims Trust Problem

· 5 min read
Patrick Omoro Head of Claims at Minet Kenya.- Kenya insurance claims
Patrick Omoro Head of Claims at Minet Kenya.- Kenya insurance claims

Kenya’s Insurance Industry Needs a Genuine Shift in How It Thinks About Claims

By Patrick Omoro

A friend of mine, a businessman, called me one evening a few weeks ago. His car had been written off in an accident. Thankfully, no one was seriously hurt, but the vehicle was gone.

He had comprehensive insurance cover, had paid his premiums consistently for four years, and yet three weeks after filing his claim, he had not received a single meaningful update. No phone call. No email. Just an acknowledgement receipt followed by what he described as complete silence.

At the end of the conversation, he asked me a simple but troubling question: “Did I make a mistake buying this policy?”

That question captures the deeper challenge Kenya’s insurance industry must confront. We sell millions of policies, but when a customer faces a genuine moment of loss, that is the only point at which insurance truly proves its value and too often, we are failing that test.

Insurance is built on a promise, but its credibility is not established when the promise is made. It is established when the promise is fulfilled. Today, many customers are left feeling exactly the way my friend did: uncertain, ignored, and quietly regretting that they ever signed up.

The claims function, still largely fragmented and transactional, is struggling to keep pace with rising customer expectations and evolving risks. Complaints data from the Insurance Regulatory Authority (IRA) paints a concerning picture. Complaints have risen by approximately 26 per cent, with general insurance accounting for the majority.

Strip away the technical language and most complaints come down to the same frustrations: customers waited too long, received less compensation than expected, or were never clearly told why decisions were made.

That is not merely a regulatory issue. It is a trust issue and in an industry where trust is the entire business model, a trust deficit becomes existential.

The numbers, however, are only symptoms. The deeper problem is structural.

Kenya’s claims process is still designed around institutional convenience. Insurers, brokers, assessors, investigators, repairers, and other stakeholders often operate in silos, each with separate timelines and varying definitions of urgency.

The problem begins even earlier, at the point of sale. Policy documents remain dense, exclusions are buried in fine print, and sales conversations are often driven by price rather than understanding.

As a result, many customers only discover the true terms of their cover when making a claim. When a claim is later declined on a technicality they never meaningfully understood, they do not experience it as a contractual outcome. They experience it as a trap.

And perceptions matter.

Those experiences spread quickly through families, businesses and communities, reinforcing long-standing skepticism toward insurance.

It is therefore unsurprising that insurance penetration in Kenya has remained stubbornly low at approximately 2.4 per cent of GDP below Africa’s regional average of 3.5 per cent and far below the global average of 7.4 per cent, according to the Allianz Global Insurance Report 2025.

Affordability is often cited as the primary reason for low uptake, but that explanation only tells part of the story. Many people who can afford insurance have simply decided the trust risk is too high. Looking at the complaints data, it is difficult to entirely fault that conclusion.

To be fair, the industry’s challenges are real. Fraud remains significant. Claims inflation is a genuine concern. Verification processes exist for good reason because, without them, the system could easily be exploited into unsustainable losses.

The issue is not that insurers conduct due diligence. The issue is that from the customer’s perspective, due diligence often feels indistinguishable from resistance.

A customer waiting three weeks for feedback has no visibility into whether their claim is being carefully assessed or quietly deprioritised. In the absence of communication, people naturally assume the worst and they rarely keep those experiences to themselves.

These concerns are not theoretical. They emerged strongly during discussions at the inaugural Minet Kenya Claims Conference held recently.

Three urgent priorities stood out.

First, the industry must communicate more honestly and clearly at the point of sale. Customers deserve to understand exactly what they are buying in plain language, not hidden within technical clauses and small print. A customer who fully understands their cover is less likely to feel blindsided and more likely to renew their policy.

Second, there must be clear accountability throughout the claims process. At present, the process has many participants but, in practice, no single accountable owner. That fragmentation creates delays, confusion and frustration.

Third, the industry must avoid treating technology as a complete solution. Digital tools can improve efficiency, but technology alone cannot repair trust. Poor communication delivered through faster systems still results in a poor experience. At moments of crisis, customers want reassurance that there is a real human being listening, guiding and responding.

My friend eventually received his settlement. It took six weeks and multiple follow-up calls he should never have had to make.

He has since moved to another insurer and is uncertain whether he will purchase comprehensive cover again at all.

That is the true cost of a broken promise. It is not simply one lost customer. It is one more person who will spend years sharing their negative experience whenever the subject of insurance comes up.

The industry already has the data. Regulators have already sent the signals.

The real question is whether insurers are prepared to fundamentally rethink claims not as a back-office process or cost centre, but as the product itself.

The policy is the promise. The claim is the proof.

Every time the industry keeps that promise, it earns something no advertising budget can buy: trust.

Every time it fails, it loses something no marketing campaign can recover.

The writer is Associate General Manager, Risk Solutions at Minet.

Follow us on Twitter and Facebook for more updates.

WRITTEN BY Nairobi Lifestyle Editor
More from Nairobi

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Keep reading

Back to home

Nairobi, straight to your inbox.

The best of the city’s events, culture, money and tech, picked by our editors.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.